Would Erwin have supported Eren's Rumbling Plan?

Key Takeaways

  • Erwin's calculated ruthlessness may have supported Eren's Rumbling plan as a strategic deterrent to Marley.
  • Erwin's pragmatism and strategic thinking could have led to a diplomatic solution rather than Eren's complete destruction.
  • Erwin's legacy as a leader suggests he would support a softened Rumbling, using it as a deterrent rather than an apocalyptic measure.



in attack on titanLeadership and morality are deeply intertwined themes that force characters to make impossible choices in order to survive. After discovering Marley and the outside world, the story tests the characters' resolve by asking questions about how far they will go to protect humanity. Although their methods are different, leaders like Eren and Erwin have opposing ideals. They share one thing in common: they give up everything for an idea. As we discover what drives these characters, the personal and moral quandaries they find themselves in are revealed.

One of the most interesting “what ifs” attack on titan If Erwin Smith had survived, here's whether he would have supported Eren's controversial Rumbling plan. His calculated ruthlessness was essential to many of his victories within the walls. The question is, does that pragmatism extend to disruptive movements like the Rumbling? It's anyone's guess. Of course, speculation will lead us to examine Erwin's character, his motivations, and what kind of reaction there will be in relation to the threat Marley poses.


Attack on Titan: What if Eren and Armin joined forces to fight Marley?

Could Eren and Armin have achieved freedom together without mass destruction?

Erwin's ideals and ruthlessness

A dream realized by my father's death

Erwin

His journey began with the death of his father, who came up with the theory that beyond the Wall was where humanity existed. This view was rejected by both society and the government. It gave Erwin a deep-rooted confidence to know if this was true, even if it cost him his life. Unlike most of the people within the walls, he knew that there might be life out there somewhere in this world, and he shaped his worldview to unlock the secrets hidden from the public eye. The mysterious circumstances of his father's death further strengthened his resolve to defy the odds and ultimately prove his father right.


His search for the truth often led him into gray moral areas. He is known for his sacrifice, and Erwin, like Eren, weighed his personal ambitions against the greater good at every moment. For Erwin, any risk worth taking was fair game, even if it meant putting his comrades in danger. This bestial ambition that transcends ethics would later draw parallels with Eren's mindset when confronting the Marleyan threat.

Erwin and Eren’s mindset

Knowing that success requires sacrifice

Erwin Smith

Both Erwin and Eren express a certain level of single-minded determination that makes them tenacious in the pursuit of their respective visions. For Erwin, this entailed obtaining the answers he believed lay beyond the Wall, while for Eren it was a matter of ensuring the safety and freedom of the Eldians at all costs. In pushing their agenda, each took morally complex actions that they found acceptable, but which seemed extreme to others.


In many ways, Erwin's mindset is similar to the determination that Eren had later in the series. Although Irwin has never committed acts as extreme as mass murder, many of his plans have consisted of sacrifices that would be taboo in most people's moral code. Bearing in mind Erwin's pragmatic nature, he probably views Rumbling as the lesser of two evils. But how much he will tolerate this is anyone's guess.

Would Erwin have supported the Rumbling?

A leader's calculation in the face of total war

Attack on Titan Erwin and Eren


Had Erwin lived to learn of Marley's involvement and oppression of the Eldians, he might have adopted a more strategic solution to this new threat. His curiosity finally quenched when he discovered Marley's presence. Erwin's ambitions probably went towards the security of the Eldians without their complete destruction. Instead of rumbling, he had a great ability to observe situations in overlooked ways, giving him the opportunity to create some sort of diplomacy or other.

But at the same time, Erwin was a realist and knew that the Marleyans had fostered and passed down their hatred of the Eldians for generations. Therefore, he may have agreed to the Rumbling as a deterrent to further attacks, but may not have agreed to Eren's proposed course of action to wipe out most of humanity. So Erwin was probably presenting a balanced argument that used Rumbling more as leverage instead of an actual plan.

Erwin's reaction to Eren's actions

Coaching or confronting a former colleague

Eren and Erwin


Eren's actions in Rumbling, an extreme measure based on his will to defend Paradis, would have earned him some sympathy from Erwin. He may have recognized the utility of Eren's power in forcing Marley and the rest of the world to negotiate their positions. Conversely, as a tactician, he would certainly have objected to the scale of Eren's plan, and would have instead orchestrated controlled use to create balance rather than genocide.

If Erwin was deeply opposed to Eren's methods, he might have tried to stop him by proposing another solution. Because we already know how desperate Eren was to force Hanji if he knew a better way, knowing what the moral implications were and what the cost would be. Complete destruction may have occurred in Paradis. Or, he could have negotiated with Eren and presented a vision to protect the Eldians without destroying the entire world. Such guidance would have changed the course of Eren's plan and perhaps even softened the blow of the conflict.


How could the results have changed?

Paradis and Eldia take different paths.

Erwin Smith (Attack on Titan)

If Erwin influenced the course of events for Eren attack on titan It would have been different. While Eren decided to wage all-out war, Erwin would have steered the story toward a negotiating approach that appealed to the interests of both Paradis and the outside world. Perhaps his strategic thinking would have allowed Erwin to solve the problem at hand, save Eldia from throwing the world into chaos, and chart a new path toward peace.

Another example of this parallel universe would be whether Paradis should coexist in a state of tension where neither Marley nor the world is completely devastated. With Erwin in command of Paradis, the defenders could have been prepared to make a limited show of force to prevent a diplomatic stalemate, leaving room for additional alliances or interests.


Potential impact on rumbling plans

A leader in conflict between ideals and reality

Erwin Rage

Erwin's legacy as a calculating yet idealistic leader speaks volumes about Eren's different approach to the Marleyan threat. Although he shared Eren's willingness to do whatever was necessary, Erwin's strategic nature and pursuit of knowledge may have led him to destructive solutions. If Erwin had supported Eren, it would have been an understated approval to use the Rumbling as a deterrent rather than an apocalyptic endgame.


The question of Erwin's hypothetical participation in the Rumbling is complex. Will his belief in a realistic approach make him willing to accept Eren's planning process, or will his ideals lead him to a more balanced approach? One thing fans can only guess about remains clear: Erwin's presence would have left an indelible mark on the storyline. attack on titan Perhaps you have met a fate that is far from what you actually met.

attack on titan

attack on titan

release date
April 7, 2013

creator
Hajime Isayama

MyAnimeList Score
8.55 (Season 1)

Leave a Comment